A “Do Nothing” Plan To Reduce The Deficit For A “Do-Nothing” Congress

Up until now, I have had nothing to say about the so-called deficit reduction “Super Committee.” They have been wasting the nation’s time and money in a deadlock which everyone knew would be the case and which has persisted since August. Now their deadline looms. By this Wednesday, they are supposed to present to Congress completed legislation, ready to vote on, which will reduce the Federal budget deficit by $1.2 trillion over the ten years beginning with fiscal year 2013. If they fail to achieve their task, then a process called “sequestration” will do the same thing — remove $120 billion per year from the Federal budget automatically, half from Defense discretionary spending, and half from non-Defense discretionary spending.

The committee will fail. Everyone has always known they would. Anyone who said different, any pundit, any member of Congress or the Senate, or the President, was playing cynical games.

Here is a chart which shows what we are talking about. The source of the chart is explained below.

The Effect On The Deficit Of The Do-Nothing Budget Compared To Current Law

Note the remarks at the bottom of the chart. Both scenarios reflect a gradual phase down of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. The “Do Nothing” budget assumes that the sequestration process created by the Debt Ceiling legislation remains in place. By fiscal year 2015, the annual budget deficit would be about $100 billion per year, if Congress did nothing.

Ezra Klein is, among many other things, a blogger for the Washington Post. For some time now he has been writing about what he calls the “do-nothing-plan” as a means to achieve substantial deficit reduction.

It’s very simple. Congress goes home to, in Mr Klein’s words, “spend more time with their campaign contributors.” While they are gone, the Bush tax cuts automatically expire, the 1997 Balanced Budget Act’s scheduled Medicare cuts kick in, the Affordable Care Act is implemented, and the budget moves roughly into balance.

It’s not an ideal way to balance the budget. The next two fiscal years would be extremely painful for both the Defense Department and the rest of us. But this “do-nothing” budget “helps clarify that the deficit is the result of votes Congress expects to cast over the next few years. If, instead of casting those votes, they do nothing, or pay for the things they choose to do, the deficit mostly disappears.”

According to Mr Klein, “The last few years have added new elements to the do-nothing plan: the triggered sequestration, for instance, and various temporary tax cuts Congress has been extending. James Horney of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities ran the numbers for Mr Klein’s colleague E. J. Dionne, and he says the do-nothing plan would now lead to $7.1 trillion in deficit reduction — more than even the Fiscal Commission envisioned. Here’s how it breaks down:”

— $3.3 trillion from letting temporary income and estate tax cuts enacted in 2001, 2003, 2009, and 2010 expire on schedule at the end of 2012 (presuming Congress also lets relief from the Alternative Minimum Tax expire, as noted below);

— $0.8 trillion from allowing other temporary tax cuts (the “extenders” that Congress has regularly extended on a “temporary” basis) expire on schedule;

— $0.3 trillion from letting cuts in Medicare physician reimbursements scheduled under current law (required under the Medicare Sustainable Growth Rate formula enacted in 1997, but which have been postponed since 2003) take effect;

— $0.7 trillion from letting the temporary increase in the exemption amount under the Alternative Minimum Tax expire, thereby returning the exemption to the level in effect in 2001;

— $1.2 trillion from letting the sequestration of spending required if the Joint Committee does not produce $1.2 trillion in deficit reduction take effect; and

— $0.9 trillion in lower interest payments on the debt as a result of the deficit reduction achieved from not extending these current policies.

Put another way, all we need to do to solve our deficit problem, is to do nothing. And all we need to do to avoid creating one is to enforce PAYGO rules in Congress. The Democrats are willing and every piece of legislation they have introduced has included a method to pay for it. Up till now, the Republicans have refused to do this. So who is really interested in dealing with the deficit?

Of course, the deficit is a phony issue. The Teabaggers seized on it as their signature issue and forced a multitude of policies onto a country which didn’t want them. They now control the House of Representatives, and are able to block any legislation they don’t like in the Senate.

The huge deficit we are hearing about continually was cynically created by Congress, which was under Republican control from 2001 until early 2007, and a Republican President. They passed a variety of tax cuts and extensions and delays, all of which favored the rich, and made no attempt to replace the money that this cost our government. They started two wars which weren’t paid for. They created Medicare Part D, ostensibly intended as drug coverage but was really meant as a gift to drug companies. This also was was not paid for. Congress and the President did more besides, which is clear from the list just above.

By the time they were done, the government was spending well over $1 trillion above what it took in in taxes. This was deliberate. This was a deliberate attempt to choke off the government’s ability to deal with emergencies and social issues. Republicans could now respond to every emergency and social crisis by bleating the meme that such things were too expensive, the government couldn’t afford it. We have all seen the results of this dishonest scheme by the Republicans — a recession which will not end, an obscenely high unemployment rate, and an economy which is barely stumbling along. Remember this when you vote next November. You don’t give another brick to a thug who has smashed all your windows with bricks.

This entry was posted in Political Events Affecting Social Security. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s